Mon–Sun: 12 AM–11:30 PM Serving Columbus since 1994

When to Replace Your Sump Pump

Three warning signs Columbus homeowners shouldn't ignore before the next storm.

When to Replace Your Sump Pump

Get in touch

Call, text, or schedule online

★★★★★
“Safe electric and plumbing always gets out quickly and it is easy to find appointments. …”
Lauren M. · Google review

Signs Your Sump Pump Is Failing

During a stormy Ohio summer, your sump pump may need to work overtime to keep water out of your basement and away from your foundation. It's easy to trust that the pump is doing its job. Until the day it isn't. Most models are built to last an average of 7 to 10 years. If yours is getting close to that mark, or if it's been showing signs of strain, it's worth having a qualified plumber take a look before the next heavy rain arrives.

Below are three of the most common warning signs that your sump pump needs attention, whether that's a repair or a full replacement.

Matt Wehrle

Written by

Matt Wehrle · Owner, Safe Electric & Plumbing & Plumbing

Frequently Cycling On and Off

A sump pump that kicks on and off too often is telling you something isn't right. The most common culprit is a float switch that's stuck or positioned incorrectly. It triggers the pump before enough water has actually accumulated, so the pump runs in short, repeated bursts. Over time, that constant start-stop cycle wears out the motor faster than normal operation would. If the float switch checks out, the problem may be that the pump is undersized for your pit. A pit that fills quickly and needs to be emptied frequently will overwhelm a pump that wasn't sized for that volume. An experienced plumber can measure your pit's refill rate and tell you whether a higher-GPH (gallons per hour) model would solve the problem. Left unaddressed, frequent cycling shortens the pump's lifespan considerably, and a pump that's running constantly when it shouldn't be is one that's more likely to fail during the storm you need it most.

Running Nonstop

A sump pump that never shuts off has one of a few likely problems: a malfunctioning float switch, a failed check valve, or a capacity mismatch between the pump and the job it's being asked to do. A failed check valve is worth explaining. When the pump shuts off, water in the discharge line can flow back down into the pit if the check valve isn't holding. The pump then senses water, kicks back on, and the cycle repeats. The pump never gets a rest. The other possibility is that the pump simply isn't powerful enough for the volume of water entering the pit, or the discharge line runs too long a distance. In either case, the pump runs continuously trying to keep up, and eventually burns out. Upgrading to a model with greater GPH capacity, or reviewing the discharge line layout, can fix this for good. Our plumbing team can assess which issue you're dealing with.

Not Kicking On When It Should

If you walk down to your basement and find water pooling on the floor, your pump either failed to activate or failed to keep up. The cause could be a tripped breaker, a failed motor, a stuck float, or, if you've had a recent power outage, the absence of a battery backup. A power outage during a storm is exactly when you need your sump pump most, and a pump without a battery backup goes silent the moment the lights go out. Adding a battery backup system is one of the more straightforward upgrades a plumber can make, and it's good insurance for any Columbus home that sees a wet spring or summer. There's also the possibility that water isn't coming from the pit at all. It could be a leaking pipe or a drainage issue that a sump pump was never designed to handle. A licensed plumber can trace the source and tell you what you're actually dealing with. If you're seeing standing water and aren't sure why, it's worth a call before you assume the pump is the problem.

When to Call Safe

Not every sump pump problem needs a full replacement, but you won't know until someone looks at it.

Unusual Noises

Grinding, rattling, or labored motor sounds usually mean a worn impeller or failing motor bearing. Neither problem fixes itself.

Visible Rust or Corrosion

Surface rust on the casing can accelerate once it starts. If the corrosion reaches internal components, the motor is next.

No Battery Backup

If your pump has no backup power source and Columbus loses electricity during a storm, your basement has no protection. A battery backup is a straightforward add-on.

Safe Plumbing Can Keep Your Basement Dry

Safe Electric & Plumbing has been keeping Central Ohio homes dry and code-compliant since 1994. Our plumbers handle everything from a simple float switch swap to a full sump pump replacement with battery backup, and we'll tell you which one your situation actually calls for. We also handle sewer and drain issues that can contribute to basement water problems, so if the sump pump isn't the whole story, we can keep looking until we find the source. Call (614) 267-4111 to schedule a visit. We're available nearly 24/7.

Call (614) 267-4111
replace sump pump work, illustration in Columbus, OH

More From the Safe Blog

Articles to help Columbus homeowners stay ahead of electrical and plumbing problems.